Jie Yang1,*, Qinqin Zhao1
1 School of Management, Northwest University of Political Science and Law, Xi’an 710122,China
How executives perceive a negative event is a fundamental component of how organizations respond after a negative event. In this paper, we empirically analyze the differences in the choice of crisis response strategies between acknowledgement and denial from the perspective of organizational executives after a negative report. The results show that SOEs prefer the "deny" strategy, which takes less responsibility, to the "acknowledge" strategy, which takes more responsibility, after a negative report. The study further finds that social status has an opposite effect on the choice of organizational defensive impression management strategies for both SOEs and private enterprises. Specifically, high-social-status SOEs prefer acknowledgement to low-social-status SOEs prefer denial, and high-social-status private enterprises prefer denial to low-social-status private enterprises prefer acknowledgement. The type of negative report plays a negative moderating role on the relationship between social status and strategy choice in SOEs and private enterprises. For high-social status SOEs, they prefer acknowledgement to indefensible negative stories and denial to indefensible stories, while the opposite result is observed for low-social status SOEs. For high-social status private firms, they prefer to deny the negative report when faced with a defensible negative report, and prefer to admit the negative report when faced with an indefensible negative report, while the opposite result is found for low-social status private firms. The findings contribute to the understanding of the differences in the choice of corporate impression management strategies of different controlling shareholders and fill the gap in the research on the differences in organizational behavior after negative reports.
executives,political purpose, reporting type, state-owned enterprises, private companies
Jie Yang, Qinqin Zhao. An Empirical Study of Crisis Response Strategy Selection Based on Executive Perspective. Academic Journal of Business & Management (2020) Vol. 2, Issue 7: 147-160. https://doi.org/10.25236/AJBM.2020.020717.
 Arndt M. and BigelowB.(2000). Presenting Structural Innovation in an Institutional Environment: Hospitals' Use of Impression Management. Administrative Science Quarterly, vol.45, no.Sept, p.494-522
 Basil D Z and Erlandson J (2008). Corporate social responsibility website representations: A longitudinal study of internal and external self‐presentations. Journal of Marketing Communications, vol.14, no.2, p.125-137.
 Beddewela E and Fairbrass J (2015). Seeking Legitimacy Through CSR: Institutional Pressures and Corporate Responses of Multinationals in Sri Lanka. Journal of Business Ethics, p.1-20.
 B R SchlenkerandWeigold M F (1992). Interpersonal processes involving impression regulation and management. Annual Review of Psychology, vol.43, no.1, p.133-168.
 Conway S. L., O’Keefe P. A. and Hrasky S. L (2015). Legitimacy, accountability and impression management in NGOs: the Indian Ocean tsunami. Accounting Auditing & Accountability Journal, vol.28, no.7, p.1075-1098.
 Cooper S. and Slack R (2015). Reporting practice, impression management and company performance: a longitudinal and comparative analysis of water leakage disclosure. Accounting & Business Research, vol.45, no.6-7, p.801-840.
 Fligstein N. and Mcadam D (2012). A Theory of Fields. Oxford University Press, vol.4, no.3, p.137.
 King B. G.and Whetten D. A (2008). Rethinking the Relationship Between Reputation and Legitimacy: A Social Actor Conceptualization. Corporate Reputation Review, vol.11, no.3, p.192-207.
 King B G, Felin T and Whetten D A (2010). Perspective---Finding the Organization in Organizational Theory: A Meta-Theory of the Organization as a Social Actor. Organization Science, vol.21 ,no.1, p.290-305.
 Koopmans R and Olzak S (2004). Discursive Opportunities and the Evolution of Right‐Wing Violence in Germany. American Journal of Sociology, vol.110, no.1, p.198-230.
 Leary M R and Kowalski R M(1990). Impression Management: A Literature Review and Two-ComponentModel. Psychological Bulletin, vol.107, no.1, p.34-47.
 Lillqvist E and Louhiala-Salminen L (2013). Facing Facebook: Impression Management Strategies in Company-Consumer Interactions. Journal of Business & Technical Communication, vol. 28, no.1, p.3-30.
 Mohamed A. A., Gardner W. L. and Paolillo J G. P (1999). A taxonomy of organizational impression management tactics. American society for competitiveness, vol.7, no.1, p.108-130.
 Mary-Hunter McDonnell and Brayden King (2013). Keeping up Appearances Reputational Threat and Impression Management after Social Movement Boycotts. Administrative Science Quarterly, vol. 58, no.3, p.387-419
 Mohamed A A (2004). An exploratory study of interorganizational defamation: an organizational impression management perspective . Organizational Analysis, vol. 12, no.2, p.129-145.
 Neu D, Warsame H and Pedwell K.(1998). Managing Public Impressions: Environmental Disclosures in Annual Reports a. Accounting Organizations & Society, vol.23, no.3, p.265-282.
 O'Grady M A(2013). Alcohol self-presentation: the role of impression motivation and impression construction. Journal of Applied Social Psychology, vol. 43, no.4, p.854–869.
 Oliver C.(1991). Strategic responses to institutional processes. Academy of Management Review, vol.16, no.1, p.145-179.
 Rahman S.(2012). Impression Management Motivations, Strategies and Disclosure Credibility of Corporate Narratives. Journal of Management Research, vol. 4, no.3.
 Rhee M and Valdez M E (2009). Contextual factors surrounding reputational damage with potential implications for reputation repair. Academy of Management Review, vol.34, no.1, p.146-168
 Schniederjans D., Cao E. S. and Schniederjans M (2013). Enhancing financial performance with social media: An impression management perspective. Decision Support Systems, vol.55, no.55, p.911-918.
 Spear S, Roper S. (2013). Using corporate stories to build the corporate brand: an impression management perspective. Journal of Product & Brand Management, vol. 22, no.22, p.491-501.
 Turnley W H and Bolino M C(2001). Achieving desired images while avoiding undesired images: exploring the role of self-monitoring in impression management. Journal of Applied Psychology, vol.86, no.2, p.351-60.
 Tata J and Prasad S (2015). CSR Communication: An Impression Management Perspective. Journal of Business Ethics, vol.132, no.4, p.765-778.
 Tilly C.(2008). Contentious performances. Cambridge University Press.
 Washington M and Zajac E J (2005). Status evolution and competition: theory and evidence . Academy of Management Journal, vol.48, no.2, p.282-296.
 Winter S. J., Saunders C. and Hart P. (2003). Electronic window dressing: impression management with Websites. European Journal of Information Systems, vol.12, no.4, p.309-322.
 Whetten D. A. and Mackey A (2002). A Social Actor Conception of Organizational Identity and Its Implications for the Study of Organizational Reputation. Business & Society, vol.41, no.4, p.393-414
 Zhang J and Luo X R (2013). Dared to Care: Organizational Vulnerability, Institutional Logics, and MNCs’ Social Responsiveness in Emerging Markets. Organization Science, vol.24, no.6, p.1742-1764.
 Min Ding (2013). A Study of Executive Compensation Decisions in State-Owned Enterprises in Monopolistic Industries.Hefei University of Technology Press
 ZhengFang, MinghuaJiang and Yang Yang (2010).A Study of the Impact of Product Injury Crisis Response Strategies on Brand Equity: The Moderating Role of Corporate Reputation and Crisis Types.Managing the World, no.12, p.105-118.
 Hui Huang (2013). Negative Media Coverage, Market Reaction, and Corporate Performance.China Soft Science, no.8, p.104-116.
 QunHui Huang,HuaGang Peng and HongWu Zhong (2009). China Top 100 Corporate Social Responsibility Development Status Evaluation.China's Industrial Economy, no.10, p.23-35
 Ming Jia, HongFei Ruan and Zhe Zhang (2014). Research on the Rumor Suppression Effect of Clarification Announcements of Public Companies. Management Science, vol.27, no.2, p.118-132.
 YanPin Liao (2015). On the Legal Regulation of Monopolistic Behavior of State-Owned Enterprises in China.Managing the World,no.5, p.182-183.
 ChunLin Liu,Ning Zhang (2012). A Study of the Clarifying Effects of Public Company Anecdotal Evidence: Evidence from the Chinese Securities Market. Journal of Management Science, vol.15, no.5, p.42-54.
 XiaoYu Wang,GangLing Zhao and JiYuan Wu (2006). The Impact of Product Injury Crises and Their Handling on Consumer Considerations.Managing the World, no.5, p.86-95.
 Lei Xing (2013). The Establishment of Crisis Public Relations System for State-owned Enterprises. China Business Guide, no.13.
 Biao Xu,YuanYuan Zhang and Xun Zhang (2014). A Study of Impaired Consumer Trust and Spillover Mechanisms after Negative Events.Management Science, vol.27,no.2, p.95-107.
 HaiNing Yan and HongMei Wang (2009). Source of profit analysis of state-owned enterprises: administrative monopoly or technological innovation. Reformation, no.11, p.128-133.
 Wei Zhang and LiangChun Yu (2011). Study on the Formation and Governance Mechanism of Industry Administrative Monopoly.China's Industrial Economy, vol.1, p.69-78.
 Min Zhang, ChengFang Wang and HuiLong Liu (2013). Redundancy Burden and Executive Incentives in State-Owned Enterprises.Financial Research, no.5, p.140-151.
 ZhiGang Zheng, DongXu Li and Rong Xu etc(2012). Political Promotion and Image Engineering in a State-Owned Enterprise: A Case Study of an N. Province A Company.Managing the World,no.10,p.146-156.
 LiAn Zhou (2007). A Study of the Promotion Tournament Model for Local Officials in China.Economic Research,no.7,p.5-36.