Welcome to Francis Academic Press

International Journal of Frontiers in Engineering Technology, 2021, 3(9); doi: 10.25236/IJFET.2021.030905.

Review on Effectiveness Evaluation of Missile Weapon System


Xinwei Zhang, Yaxiong Li, Jiufen Zhao and Xinzhi Yang

Corresponding Author:
Xinwei Zhang

Xi’an High-tech Institute, Xi’an 710025, PR China


In order to evaluate and compare the advantages and disadvantages of missile weapon systems and assist commanders in making optimal decisions, quantitative scales must be used to measure the effectiveness of missile weapon systems. This paper introduces the concept of missile weapon system effectiveness, expounds the importance and necessity of effectiveness evaluation, summarizes the relevant models, common methods and development process of effectiveness evaluation, analyzes the problems faced by missile weapon system effectiveness evaluation, and looks forward to the development trend of this research field.


Missile weapon system, System Effectiveness, Effectiveness evaluation, Auxiliary decision

Cite This Paper

Xinwei Zhang, Yaxiong Li, Jiufen Zhao and Xinzhi Yang. Review on Effectiveness Evaluation of Missile Weapon System. International Journal of Frontiers in Engineering Technology (2021), Vol. 3, Issue 9: 30-35. https://doi.org/10.25236/IJFET.2021.030905.


[1] Jiao Song. Research on key problems of the simulation evaluation for weapon effectiveness [D]. Harbin: Harbin Institute of Technology, 2014. 

[2] Dordick H S. An introduction to system effectiveness [R]. Rand. 1965. 

[3] Hayward P. The measurement of combat effectiveness [J]. Operations Research (S0030-364X), 1968, 16(2): 314-323. 

[4] Tillman F A, Lie C H, Hwang C L. Simulation model for mission effectiveness for military systems [J]. IEEE Transactions on Reliability (S0018-9529), 1978, 27(3): 191-194. 

[5] Bouthonnier V, Levis A H. System effectiveness analysis of C3 systems [J]. IEEE Transactions on System, Man, and Cybernetics (S2168-2232), 1984, 14(1): 48-54. 

[6] Gluckman A G, Celmins A. Cost effectiveness analysis using fuzzy set theory[R]. U.S. Army Research Laboratory. 1993. 

[7] Gallagher M A, Kelly E J. New methodology for military force structure analysis [J]. Operations Research (S0030-364X), 1991, 39(6): 877-885. 

[8] Bowden F, Gabrisch C, Davies M. C3I systems analysis using the distributed interactive C3I effectiveness (DICE) simulation[C]. IEEE International Conference on Systems, Man, and Cybernetics. Los Alamitos: IEEE, 1997: 4326-4331. 

[9] Kohlberg I, Greer W. Weapons systems effectiveness and minimum cost for ballistic missile defense alternatives[C]. AIAA missile system conference. Reston: AIAA, 1996. 

[10] Horn D, Colvert P, Scrip C. THAAD integrated system effectiveness simulation (TISES) theater high altitude area defense[C]. AIAA Modeling and Simulation Technologies Conference. Reston: AIAA, 1997. 

[11] Guan Chengqi, Yang Di, Guan Shiyi. Study of effectiveness evaluation method for guided weapon systems [J]. Systems Engineering and Electronics, 2000, 22(7): 32-36. 

[12] Yang Feng, Zhang Xuebin, Wang Weiping, et al. The architecture of the simulation-based evaluation system for missile effectiveness [J]. Journal of National University of Defense Technology, 1999, 21(1): 17-20. 

[13] Pinder J D. Evaluating future force options for the U.S. army [D]. Santa Monica: RAND Graduate School, 2000. 

[14] Lund F. Historic weapon system cost effectiveness comparison[C]. AIAA Aerospace Sciences Meeting Including the New Horizons Forum and Aerospace Exposition. Reston: AIAA, 2009. 

[15] Gipson I G. Effectiveness of the U.S. missile defense capabilities as a deterrent to the North Korean missile [D]. Monterey: Naval Postgraduate School, 2007. 

[16] Zhang Ke, Liu Yongcai, Guan Shiyi. Discussion on operational effectiveness evaluation of missile weapon system [J]. Journal of Astronautics, 2002 (02): 58-66

[17] Ender T, Leurck R F, Weaver B, et al. Systems-of-systems analysis of ballistic missile defense architecture effectiveness through surrogate modeling and simulation [J]. IEEE Systems Journal (S2222-6362), 2010, 4(2): 156-166. 

[18] Connors C D, Miller J O, Lunday B J. Using agent-based modeling and a designed experiment to simulate and analyze a new air-to-air missile[J]. Journal of Defense Modeling and Simulation: Applications, Methodology, Technology (S1548-5129), 2016, 13(3): 321-330. 

[19] Hocaoğlu M F. Weapon target assignment optimization for land based multi-air defense systems: A goal programming approach [J]. Computers & Industrial Engineering (S0360-8352), 2019, 128: 681-689. 

[20] Sun Xinbo, Wang Minle, Xie Tao, et al. Simulation evaluation of conventional missile combat effectiveness in joint operations [J]. Tactical missile technology, 2009 (04): 85-88 + 80

[21] Hu Xizhen, Xia Jun, Cao Suping. Combat capability evaluation of conventional missile forces based on grey entropy weight method [J]. Ordnance automation, 2012, 31 (07): 27-30 + 48

[22] Wang Junjun, Zhu Huajin, Wang Haitao, et al. Operational effectiveness evaluation of submarine launched anti-ship missile weapon system based on group decision analytic hierarchy process [J]. Journal of Naval Academy of Aeronautical Engineering, 2017, 32 (04): 416-420

[23] Qiao Rong, Zhou Feng. Operational effectiveness evaluation of surface to air missile weapon system based on PCA-BP Neural Network [J]. Military operations research and system engineering, 2020, 34 (04): 38-43 + 67

[24] Zhang Xinwei, Li Yaxiong, Zhao Jiufen, et al. Entropy method based on complex network theory Objective value evaluation [J / OL]. Command and control and simulation https://kns.cnki.net/kcms/detail/32.1759.TJ.20211014.1956.006.html

[25] Zhou Yuchen, Lin Shenglin, Ma Ping, Li Wei, Yang Ming. Research progress of weapon equipment effectiveness evaluation [J]. Journal of system simulation, 2020, 32 (08): 1413-1424

[26] Tao Xigui, Li Yong, Huang Zili, Jia Yifan. Research on support platform for effectiveness evaluation of national defense engineering [J]. Protection engineering, 2018, 40 (05): 46-50

[27] Dou Jihua, Yu Liangsheng, Chen Wanchun. Overview of operational effectiveness evaluation of ship to air missile weapon system [J]. Modern defense technology, 2011, 39 (01): 12-18

[28] Bian Lixin, Luo Xingbai. Research progress on effectiveness evaluation method of weapon equipment system [J]. Flying missile, 2017 (07): 62-64

[29] Ma Lin, song Guibao, Luo yunbao. GAHP model for effectiveness evaluation of missile weapon system [J]. Journal of system simulation, 2006 (S2): 101-103 + 107

[30] Liu Huayun, Zhang Xianchun. Effectiveness evaluation method of missile weapon system based on ADC [J]. Ordnance automation, 2015, 34 (08): 11-14

[31] Gao Yuan, Jiang Tao. Research on operational effectiveness evaluation method of missile weapon system [J]. National defense manufacturing technology, 2017 (02): 56-57 + 55

[32] Zhang Anli, Li Zhi, Diao Huafei. Threat factor analysis and Countermeasures in missile operation [J]. Aeronautical missile, 2015 (08): 69-72

[33] Chen Qifeng, Dai Jinhai. Agent synthesis method for combat effectiveness of aerospace equipment system [J]. Journal of system simulation, 2011, 23 (11): 2352-2356