Frontiers in Medical Science Research, 2022, 4(5); doi: 10.25236/FMSR.2022.040509.
Luying Qi1, Jian Feng2, Zuojing Feng2, Zhenzhen Hu1, Zhihua Ma3, Nina Qin1, Chujie Hou1, Chenyi Zhang1, Yang Lu3, Liyong Chen1,2
1School of Public Health, Cheeloo College of Medicine, Shandong University, Jinan, 250012, China
2Department of Nutrition, Qilu Hospital of Shandong University, Jinan, 250012, China
3School of Public Health, Shandong First Medical University, Jinan, 250024, China
Background: Diabetic constipation is a common complication of diabetes mellitus(DM), which not only leads to pains of patients such as abdominal pain and abdominal distention, but increases the economic burden of patients and society. Whether external therapy of traditional Chinese medicine(TCM) an effective way to treat diabetic constipation has not yet come to a conclusion. Therefore, this study aimed to evaluate the efficacy of TCM external therapy for treating diabetic constipation. Methods: We searched 7 databases from inception to 21 December, 2021. The databases included PubMed, Embase, Cochrane Library, China National Knowledge Infrastructure (CNKI), WanFang database, China Science and Technology Journal Database (VIP) and Chinese BioMedical Literature Database(CBM). All analyses were conducted by RevMan5.4 and Stata12.0. The Cochrane risk of bias assessment tool was used for quality assessment and risk of bias assessment. Results: A total of 40 RCTs were included in the meta-analysis, involving 3074 diabetic constipation patients. The results showed that TCM external therapy increased in total effective rate and weekly defecation times compared with control group. TCM external therapy also showed more reduction in defecation time, fecal traits score and FBS level than control group. Conclution: TCM external therapy effectively relieves the costive symptom of DM patients. This meta-analysis demonstrated that TCM external therapy was more effective in treating diabetic constipation patients than common therapy or routine defecation medicine. However, the quality of most included studies were low. More multicenter, randomized, double-blind, and placebo controlled clinical trials will be needed in the future.
Traditional Chinese Medicine, External therapy, Diabetic constipation, Meta-analysis
Luying Qi, Jian Feng, Zuojing Feng, Zhenzhen Hu, Zhihua Ma, Nina Qin, Chujie Hou, Chenyi Zhang, Yang Lu, Liyong Chen. Effectiveness of Traditional Chinese Medicine External Therapy for Diabetic Constipation: A Meta-Analysis. Frontiers in Medical Science Research (2022) Vol. 4, Issue 5: 47-58. https://doi.org/10.25236/FMSR.2022.040509.
[1] Prasad VG, Abraham P. Management of chronic constipation in patients with diabetes mellitus [J]. Indian J Gastroenterol, 2017,36 (1):11-22.
[2] Ueno N, Inui A, Satoh Y. The effect of mosapride citrate on constipation in patients with diabetes [J]. Diabetes Res Clin Pract, 2010,87(1):27-32.
[3] Gatopoulou A, Papanas N, Maltezos E. Diabetic gastrointestinal autonomic neuropathy: current status and new achievements for everyday clinical practice[J]. Eur J Intern Med, 2012,23(6):499-505.
[4] Ron Y, Wainstein J, Leibovitz A, Monastirsky N, Habot B, Avni Y, et al. The effect of acarbose on the colonic transit time of elderly long-term care patients with type 2 diabetes mellitus[J]. J Gerontol A Biol Sci Med Sci, 2002,57(2):M111-4.
[5] Sumida K, Molnar MZ, Potukuchi PK, Thomas F, Lu JL, Matsushita K, et al. Constipation and Incident CKD[J]. J Am Soc Nephrol, 2017,28(4):1248-1258.
[6] Tomita T, Kazumori K, Baba K, Zhao X, Chen Y, Miwa H. Impact of chronic constipation on health-related quality of life and work productivity in Japan[J]. J Gastroenterol Hepatol, 2021,36(6):1529-1537.
[7] Ghadiri-Anari A, Gholami S, Zolfaghari F, Namiranian N. Prediabetes and gastrointestinal (GI) symptoms; a cross-sectional study[J]. Diabetes Metab Syndr, 2019,13(1):844-846.
[8] Patel K, Horak H, Tiryaki E. Diabetic neuropathies[J]. Muscle Nerve, 2021,63(1):22-30.
[9] Brock C, Søfteland E, Gunterberg V, Frøkjær JB, Lelic D, Brock B, et al. Diabetic autonomic neuropathy affects symptom generation and brain-gut axis[J]. Diabetes Care, 2013,36(11):3698-3705.
[10] Meldgaard T, Keller J, Olesen AE, Olesen SS, Krogh K, Borre M, et al. Pathophysiology and management of diabetic gastroenteropathy[J]. Therap Adv Gastroenterol, 2019,12:1756284819852047.
[11] Wen JM, Zhuang ZJ, Zhao MH, Xie DM, Xie B, Zhuang LX, et al. Treatment of poststroke constipation with moxibustion[J]. Medicine, 2018,97(24):e11134.
[12] Greenslade R. Osmotic and stimulant laxatives for the management of childhood constipation[J]. Int J Nurs Pract, 2017,23(2).
[13] Chen YJ, Zhu YN, Feng XH, Shen Q, Luo Y, Hu ZH, et al. Treatment of type 2 diabetic constipation with qi-Yin deficiency by zengye Tongdefecation prescription combined with wax bag moxibustion: a clinical observation of 30 cases[J]. Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine, 2015,56(06):483-486.
[14] Li X, Xiao QQ, Ze K, Li S, Wang YF, Zhou M, et al. External Application of Traditional Chinese Medicine for Venous Ulcers: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis[J]. Evid Based Complement Alternat Med, 2015,2015:831474.
[15] Li XM. Complementary and alternative medicine in pediatric allergic disorders[J]. Curr Opin Allergy Clin Immunol, 2009,9(2):161-167.
[16] Yan XY, Yan ZS, Liu WC, Ding H, Qiao SZ, Chen G, et al. External application of traditional Chinese medicine in the treatment of bone cancer pain: a meta-analysis[J]. Support Care Cancer, 2016,24(1):11-17.
[17] Wu L, Yuan Q, Kuang Y, Chen Y, Li J, Feng Y, et al. External treatment of traditional Chinese medicine for COVID-19: A protocol for systematic review and meta-analysis[J]. Medicine (Baltimore), 2020,99(39):e22316.
[18] Yan R, Zhan J, Liu G, Li C, Cai P, Chen Y, et al. A comparison of the efficacy and safety of traditional Chinese medicine external treatment for the hyperemesis gravidarum: A protocol for systematic review and network meta-analysis[J]. Medicine (Baltimore), 2020,99(45):e23019.
[19] Yang R, Li ZY, Zhang ZW. Clinical research progress of Chinese medicineexternal treatment to treat constipation after stroke[J]. Journal of liaoning university of traditional Chinese medicine [Preprint], 2021.
[20] Yang YT. Application status of external treatment of Traditional Chinese medicine in diabetes[J]. Modern Nurse, 2015,23(08):6-7.
[21] Luo F, Wang YP, Zhu Y. The research progress of traditional Chinese medicine external treatment of functional constipation[J]. Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine Review, 2017,23(02):86-88.
[22] Sun YH, Tao HW, Liu YD. Patches apply joint other external treatment in treating constipation research progress[J]. Journal of Shandong Traditional Chinese Medicine, 2017,4(11):989-93.
[23] Bai PP. Effect of acupoint application of traditional Chinese medicine on constipation in diabetic patients[J]. Guangming Traditional Chinese Medicine, 2017,32(03):390-392.
[24] Bai WH. Electric needle treatment of diabetic constipation curative effect observation[J]. Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine Clinical Journal, 2017,29(02):251-253.
[25] Bao M, Lu YF, Feng JJ, Lu YT, Li XT. Effect of seed embedding in auricular acupoint on diabetic constipation[J]. Forum of Primary Care Medicine, 2012,16(36):4795-4796.
[26] Chen JY, Zeng QL, Peng XY. Observation on the effect of acupoint application combined with acupoint massage in the treatment of diabetic constipation patients[J]. General Nursing, 2019,17(13):1577-1579.
[27] Chen Y. Acupuncture point attach CV 8 point application in diabetes patients with constipation study[J]. Journal of Diabetes in the New World, 2018,21(17):45-46.
[28] Cui GM, Cao AM, Zuo YN, Zhou Y. Clinical observation on 70 cases of diabetes constipation with spleen kidney yang deficiency treated by acupoint application therapy[J]. China Maternal and Child Health Research, 2017,28(S3):150-151.
[29] Ding HY, Shao Y, Cai JY, Han XL, Song XH. Treatment of 38 cases of type 2 diabetes constipation with Chinese medicine umbilicus therapy[J]. Jiangxi Traditional Chinese Medicine, 2014,45(01):20-21.
[30] Fan MN, Chang LY, Yang XC. Clinical study on abdominal massage for senile diabetes constipation[J]. New Traditional Chinese Medicine, 2020,52(16):141-144.
[31] Gao YG, Zhang QQ, Wu H, Wang RH, Wang KF. Treatment of 41 cases of diabetic constipation with Zeng Ye Decoction plus gourd moxibustion[J]. Jiangxi Traditional Chinese Medicine, 2020,51(07):60-62.
[32] Gao YQ, Lu CX, Liu FS, Liu J. Randomized controlled study of Acupoint Application in treating constipation caused by type 2 diabetic gastroparesis[J]. Tianjin Traditional Chinese Medicine, 2018,35(11):829-832.
[33] Hao HH. Clinical observation of acupoint application combined with Bifidobacterium quadruple viable tablets in the treatment of senile type 2 diabetic patients with functional constipation[J]. Smart Health, 2020,6(29):78-80.
[34] Huang Y. Treatment of constipation due to yin deficiency and dryness heat by rhubarb powder and umbilicus treatment[J]. World Latest Medical Information Digest, 2017,17(95):148.
[35] Hu J, Gu WP, Zhai M. Observation on therapeutic effect of auricular point sticking nursing on diabetic constipation[J]. Journal of External Treatment of Traditional Chinese Medicine, 2014,23(06):32-3.
[36] Jin MJ, Tang CX, Dong Y. Treatment of 24 cases of diabetic constipation by "moistening intestines drink" plus oral administration and Acupoint Application of catharsis[J]. Zhejiang Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine, 2017,52(05): 340.
[37] Liu J, Huang Y, Hu PX, Zhang YJ, Zhong SQ. Effect of auricular acupoint pressing on senile diabetes patients with constipation[J]. Frontier of Medicine, 2021,11(14):168-169.
[38] Liu XY, Guo J, Yang L. Effect of abdominal acupoint massage combined with ear point embedding on diabetes mellitus with Yin deficiency, fire heat and constipation[J]. Sichuan Traditional Chinese Medicine, 2018,36(06):187-189.
[39] Liu YF, Lin HJ. Six Ingredient Rehmannia Pill Combined with Acupoint Application in the treatment of constipation in type 2 diabetes: 30 cases[J]. Yunnan Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine, 2018,39(1):67-68.
[40] Ruan LH, Mo SY. Nursing care of moxibustion combined with medicated diet in treating senile diabetes with Qi deficiency and constipation[J]. Modern Nurse, 2012,20(07):87-88.
[41] Song SS. Nursing observation on treating diabetic constipation with acupoint application and acupoint massage[J]. Guangming Traditional Chinese Medicine, 2017,32(08):1192-1193.
[42] Tan XS, Xie Y, Gao Y. Clinical observation on treating constipation of type 2 diabetes with Six Ingredient Rehmannia Pill Combined with Chinese herbal medicine point application therapy[J]. China Pharmacy, 2016,27(27):3797-3799.
[43] Tang N, Jin J, Ban Y, Cui ZL, Wang LQ, Peng H, et al. Observation of curative effect of eight segment brocade combined with moxa stick moxibustion on diabetic patients with Yang deficiency constipation[J]. Modern Distance Education of Chinese Traditional Medicine, 2016,14(20):111-112.
[44] Wang LQ, Zhu HB, Tong Y. Effect of auricular acupoint pressing on improving diabetic constipation patients[J]. China Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine, 2011,3(8):230.
[45] Wang L, Sun BL, Bao JL, Jiang Y, Xiong GH, Zhao DX. Clinical observation on treatment of constipation in elderly patients with type 2 diabetic nephropathy by auricular acupoint pressing and Shen que point sticking therapy[J]. Journal of Guangzhou University of Traditional Chinese Medicine, 2021,38(01):85-90.
[46] Wu FH, Zhou HJ, Zhu QY, Tang HT, Hu X. Observation on the therapeutic effect of "electroacupuncture combined with Mosapride" on treating diabetic constipation[J]. Chinese Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine, 2016,34(02):353-355.
[47] Wu YR. Clinical study of low frequency pulse point stimulation on patients with diabetic constipation[D]. Fujian University of traditional Chinese medicine, 2016.
[48] Xiao F, Jiang HY, Tang SG, Li RY, Chen SB. Treatment of diabetic constipation with Acupoint Application of traditional Chinese medicine[J]. Diabetes World, 2019,16(6):27.
[49] Xu CY. Clinical observation on 40 cases of diabetic constipation treated with Acupoint Application of Chinese medicine[J]. Guide to Traditional Chinese Medicine, 2013,19(07):71-72.
[50] Yang GF, Wang J, Luo M. Observation on curative effect of ear acupuncture combined with abdominal massage in treating diabetic constipation[J]. Chinese Journal of Clinical Medicine, 2016,28(12):1789-91.
[51] Yang RH, Sun LM. Clinical observation of Jiawei Zeng Ye decoction combined with Acupoint Application in the treatment of diabetic constipation[J]. Journal of Hunan University of Traditional Chinese Medicine, 2018,38(A01):343-344.
[52] Ye YY. Efficacy of Six Ingredient Rehmannia Pill Combined with Chinese herbal prescription acupoint application and Mosapride Citrate Tablets in the treatment of constipation in type 2 diabetes mellitus[J]. Inner Mongolia Traditional Chinese Medicine, 2018,37(10):62-63.
[53] Yin JX. Observation on therapeutic effect of auricular point sticking combined with Acupoint Application on diabetic constipation[J]. Xinjiang Traditional Chinese Medicine, 2019,37(06):44-45.
[54] Yu TT. Clinical study on the application of Astragalus membranaceus applying to umbilicus in patients with constipation due to Qi deficiency and diabetes mellitus[D]. Fujian University of traditional Chinese medicine, 2015.
[55] Zhang C, Tan C. Electroacupuncture at Tianshu Shang Ju Xu in the treatment of diabetic constipation: a randomized controlled trial[J]. Journal of Liaoning University of Traditional Chinese Medicine, 2010,12(04):114-116.
[56] Zhang HW. Observation and nursing care of diabetic constipation treated with Acupoint Application of Chinese herbal medicine[J]. Medical Information, 2017,30(24):156-157.
[57] Zhang W. Observation on therapeutic effect of acupuncture on constipation of diabetic gastroenteric nervous disorder[D]. Hebei North University, 2019.
[58] Zhang YG, Pu WR, Ren LM, Wang WJ. Treatment of 40 cases of diabetic constipation with syndrome differentiation therapy and auricular point sticking therapy[J]. Shaanxi Traditional Chinese Medicine, 2008,29(08):986-987.
[59] Zhao MG. Treatment of 59 cases of diabetic constipation with Yiqi Ziyin Runzao Decoction plus Acupoint Application of Xiang Jun San in treating diabetes constipation[J]. National Medical Forum, 2018,33(03):35-36.
[60] Zheng SF, Zou XY. Effect of Wu Zhuyu hot compress combined with auricular acupoint nursing on abdominal distension and gastrointestinal function in patients with diabetes constipation[J]. New Traditional Chinese Medicine, 2021,53(16):182-185.
[61] Zhou LN, Wang SL, Wu JZ. Effect of self-made Runchang pill combined with TCM nursing intervention on improving constipation in patients with diabetes mellitus[J]. Chinese Journal of Modern Nursing, 2013(19):2302-2303.
[62] Zhu SL. Intervention effect of acupoint massage combined with application on senile diabetes constipation[J]. Chinese Journal of Basic Medicine of Traditional Chinese Medicine, 2019,25(07):985-987.
[63] Piper MS, Saad RJ. Diabetes Mellitus and the Colon[J]. Curr Treat Options Gastroenterol, 2017,15(4):460-474.
[64] Yamada E, Namiki Y, Takano Y, Takamine H, Inazumi K, Sasaki H, et al. Clinical factors associated with the symptoms of constipation in patients with diabetes mellitus: A multicenter study[J]. J Gastroenterol Hepatol, 2018,33(4):863-868.
[65] Lee HY, Kwon OJ, Kim JE, Kim M, Kim AR, Park HJ, et al. Efficacy and safety of acupuncture for functional constipation: a randomised, sham-controlled pilot trial[J]. BMC Complement Altern Med, 2018,18(1):186.
[66] Wang J, Wong YK, Liao F. What has traditional Chinese medicine delivered for modern medicine[J]? Expert Rev Mol Med, 2018,20:e4.
[67] Ji LJ, Fan YH, Li LH, Bai HW, Weng LP, Zhao P. Efficacy and safety of Chinese herbal compound in the treatment of functional constipation: A protocol for systematic review and meta-analysis[J]. Medicine (Baltimore), 2020,99(39):e22456.
[68] Yao F, Zhang Y, Kuang X, Zhou Q, Huang L, Peng J, et al. Effectiveness and Safety of Moxibustion on Constipation: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis[J]. Evid Based Complement Alternat Med, 2020,2020:8645727.
[69] Tang OF, Huang SM, Ye XX, Liu QX, Chen TT, Zhan CJ. Effect of acupuncture and moxibustion on post-stroke constipation: a network Meta-analysis[J]. Zhongguo Zhen Jiu, 2020,40(9):1011-1016.
[70] Fang YP, Huang YT, Chen D, Kan Y, Wang JW, Kang XL, et al. Systematic review and Meta analysis on the effectiveness and safety of tuina in treatment of functional constipation[J]. Zhongguo Zhen Jiu, 2021,41(06):691-698.
[71] Li YH, Yin LL, Wang SX, Wang LH. Observation on the therapeutic effect of acupoint application on constipation[J]. Zhongguo Zhen Jiu, 2007,27(3):189-90.
[72] Li MK, Lee TF, Suen KP. Complementary effects of auricular acupressure in relieving constipation symptoms and promoting disease-specific health-related quality of life: A randomized placebo-controlled trial[J]. Complement Ther Med, 2014,22(2):266-277.
[73] Wei JH. Clinical study on moxibustion and auricular bean pressing combined with routine medical measures to improve senile habitual constipation[J]. New Traditional Chinese Medicine, 2021,53(12):189-192.
[74] Qiu MH. Discussion on acupoint selection of acupuncture and moxibustion in the treatment of post-stroke constipation[J]. Journal of Yunnan University of traditional Chinese medicine, 2021,44(02):62-64.
[75] Guo P, Qiu WM. Observation on the efficacy of biofeedback combined with traditional Chinese medicine massage in the treatment of 40 cases of functional constipation[J]. Chinese Journal of Anorectal Diseases, 2021,41(09):39-41.
[76] Zhao Z, Chen Y, Zhang HY. Application of rhubarb acupoint application at Shenque point in the prevention of opioid related constipation in patients with malignant tumors[J]. Qilu Journal of Nursing, 2021,27(17):155-157.
[77] Zhou XX, Zhong Y, Teng J. Treatment of senile habitual constipation by syndrome differentiation of auricular points: a randomized controlled study[J]. Chinese Acupuncture and Moxibustion, 2012,32(12):1090-1092.